The jury is out on what is the best packaging materials for packaging products, according to a survey conducted by Packaging Gateway at the Packaging Innovations and Empack packaging exhibition.
Packaging Gateway’s Ryan Ellington spoke to a number of packaging brands and attendees at the event as well as members of the general public to uncover what is deemed to be the best packaging material for a sustainable future.
Understanding the differences between plastics
Plastic packaging can come in a range of forms such as PET (polyethylene terephthalate), HDPE (high-density polyethylene), PVC (polyvinyl chloride) and PS (polystyrene). Each type provides its own benefits but not all have recyclable properties.
Looming global environmental targets have encouraged innovation within the packaging space, leading many businesses to opt for recyclable plastic packaging as an alternative sustainable solution. This has seen the introduction of many pulp-based and food-based packaging alternatives.
One of the issues that some businesses encounter is that many of the alternative packaging materials do not suit the particular needs of the product within. Rather than opting for a non-plastic sustainable material, some businesses are leaning towards “good” plastics.
Recyclable plastics (PET and HDPE) and bio-based plastics (Bio-PET or Bio-PE) are often viewed as “good” plastics due to their ability to be recycled and fit within a circular economy.
The survey conducted by Packaging Gateway, which included both packaging experts at the trade show and members of the public asked: What is the best sustainable packaging material between “good” plastics and alternative packaging materials?
The survey found almost half of the respondents (48%) view alternative materials as the best option compared to the 38% who opted for good plastics. Many of those surveyed told Packaging Gateway that moving away from plastics is the best option if it has a positive impact on the environment.
A high percentage of those that chose plastics said it has a key role to play in packaging due to its flexibility, cost and the fact there are global infrastructures in place to recycle polymers and keep them within a circular economy.
A place for plastics
Plastic pollution is widely regarded as a global health crisis and most consumers see plastics as bad, but this isn’t always the case. There is a range of recyclable plastics available on the market that fit into a circular model and some would argue that plastics within packaging are necessary to bring many products to market.
Polymer producer Liz Rettweger who is the commercial director for Ineos Olefins & Polymers Europe tells Packaging Gateway there is a place for plastics within packaging.
“There’s a place for plastics just as there is a place for aseptic (sterilised) packaging.”
She explains there are situations where it will be the best fit for a product, and adds: “It depends on the product you’re protecting, the customer base that you’re supplying, how you’re supplying it and where the customer is.”
This could explain why 14% of those surveyed by Packaging Gateway were undecided about the best sustainable solution and believe both plastics and alternative materials have a place within packaging.
Rettweger continued: “What’s really important in all kinds of packaging, is that we work on reducing its environmental impact. No matter what the package is you have to look at the carbon footprint. Look at how it’s made, how it can become more circular and even how it’s distributed to the customer.”
According to the British Plastics Federation (BPF), plastics offer unrivalled benefits such as being lightweight and offering barrier protection, whilst significantly reducing waste and saving energy. In fact, the organisation claims food waste in the UK is only 2% compared to 40-50% in developing parts of the world, due to the role that plastics play in keeping food fresh. For example, a cucumber loses moisture quickly and would be unsaleable within three days were it not protected by 1.5 grams of plastic.
A recent report by GlobalData, Packaging Gateway’s parent company titled ‘ESG in food service’ reported that an increase in negative perceptions around plastics among consumers will most likely accelerate a shift towards recyclable plastics.
“While recycling is a step in the right direction, it is not the ultimate solution to sustainability as many recyclable plastics are simply not recycled and energy is still required to turn used products into new ones. As plastics remain in circulation, they are always at risk of ending up in landfills or oceans at the end of their life,” the report explained.
In order to remove “bad” plastics from packaging and create a sustainable future, innovation is key. The practice of developing alternative sustainable packaging materials has grown over the past few years with more packaging companies bringing eco-friendly solutions to market.
For example, British chemical company Ineos recently partnered with Chinese packaging company Greatview Aseptic to develop their first sustainable aseptic packaging option, using fully bio-based products, plastic and card.
Speaking about the collaboration Ineos’ Rettweger explained: “Polymer adds a layer of protection to the food that’s packaged inside the carton packaging. By producing it in this way with 100% renewable power and producing it from bio-attributed feedstocks, it is a very sustainable solution for packaging food for the consumer.”
The creation of packaging from paper and pulp-based materials has become an increasingly popular idea with companies such as British packaging firm Frugalpac and Swedish pulp and paper manufacturer BillerudKorsnäs who implemented a sack paper to replace the plastic film barriers. Plastic was previously seen as a near necessity in keeping products fresh whilst packaged. Frugalpac, who is said to have created the world’s first commercially available paper bottle for wines, spirits and oil, recently sold the first Frugalpac Bottle Assembly Machine (FBAM-1) to Canadian packaging firm KinsBrae Packaging with the aim of pushing sustainability further.
“We looked at what we could do with some of our technology and felt we could make a lower carbon product that would be of interest to consumers as well as our customers,” said Frugalpac’s chief executive Malcolm Waugh.
He explained that whilst the Frugalpac bottle is predominately made from paper, plastics are still required to make a paper bottle that doesn’t leak.
“The package is 16% plastic film. That 16% plastic allows us to use 84% recycled content in the bottle by weight and that’s what drives the carbon down. The combination of both of those materials gives us a very sustainable package.”
Waugh added Frugalpac doesn’t contaminate its packaging by laminating the materials together. Instead, they are mechanically fitted to make the separation process easy and create a 100% recyclable package. The cross-contamination of materials is an issue suffered across the industry and according to Waugh, the recovery of film or flexible packaging is less than 4% in the UK.
Global drinks brand Carlsberg created a new bio-based fibre bottle and has launched trials across eight European markets. The bottle is a move away from glass and Carlsberg decided against using plastics, opting for a bio-based and degradable material. The bottles are made from wood fibres whilst having an inner lining of a plant-based polymer, polyethylenefuranoate (PEF).
“PEF is a revolutionary alternative polymer – not only is it made entirely from renewable raw materials, but it can retain carbon dioxide better than conventional PET plastic, so both the environment and our beer can benefit,” said Simon Boas Hoffmeyer, group sustainability director at Carlsberg. “For the inner barrier, PEF was chosen due to its sustainability credentials such as biobased, degradable and recyclable, as well as its technical properties which met our strict quality standards.”
A number of companies have started to look at or implement the idea of creating degradable packaging. British biotech startup company Shellworks created a vegan, compostable alternative to plastics with a new material called Vivomer. It is made from bacterially-derived components that are grown via a fermentation process. Compostable packaging is a wholly sustainable option, however, some believe it is only viable if there is a circular model in place to avoid it ending up in landfill.
Shellworks co-founder Amir Afshar pointed out if the recycling stream existed for the materials everything would be recycled. He said the problem with a lot of materials made from plastics however is that the recycling streams for them don’t exist. Afshar highlighted this makes it an interesting debate and says when most people think about recycling, they believe that putting items in a household recycling bin means the items will be recycled. This is not the case, he argued as in reality half of that recycling waste ends up in landfill.
“If you look at the statistics, roughly 20% of people have access to some kind of compost, maybe a little bit higher depending on where you are. But only 9% of materials ultimately get recycled, so even at that level, composable materials are about twice as effective,” explained Afshar.
What’s the solution?
The general view on the end-life of product packaging adds fuel as to why the majority lean towards alternative packaging solutions over sustainable plastic packaging. If waste is not recycled and only ends up in landfill, an alternative material with higher composable and compostable properties could be viewed as being better for the environment.
There is no definitive solution as to what the best sustainable material is for packaging. Arguably, the most important factor to consider, in order to succeed in reaching worldwide environmental targets, is whether the right sustainable packaging option is being used to achieve the best results for the product.
Innovation in packaging is key to providing options to companies and consumers alike. Packaging experts agree that consumers need options in order for the industry to prosper. Increased public awareness around the properties of the packaging materials available as well as working circular models are important factors to be considered. The experts point out that not all plastics are bad and polymer materials such as PEF and RPET are good examples of how plastics can be beneficial as long as circular models are effectively in place.