Then, he writes in translated letters shared by the Tate art museum, gradually fires were lit, and smoke and a haze of industrial pollution returned to the skies. His work continued.
A new study, published Tuesday in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, analyzed changes in style and color in nearly 100 paintings by Monet and Joseph Mallord William (J.M.W.) Turner, who are known for their impressionistic art and lived during Western Europe’s Industrial Revolution in the 18th and 19th century. The study found that over time, as industrial air pollution increased throughout Turner’s and Monet’s careers, skies in their paintings became hazier, too.
“Impressionistic painters are known to be exquisitely sensitive to changes in light and changes in the environment,” said atmospheric scientist Anna Lea Albright, lead author of the study. “It makes sense that they would be very sensitive to not only kind of natural changes in the environment, but also man-made changes.”
The early Industrial Revolution transformed lives and skies of London and Paris, the painters’ hometowns, in unprecedented ways. Coal-burning factories increased employment opportunities but obscured the atmosphere with harmful pollutants, such as sulfur dioxide.
Much of the change is apparent in the United Kingdom, which emitted nearly half of global sulfur dioxide emissions from 1800 to 1850; London accounted for around 10 percent of the U.K.’s emissions. Paris industrialized slower but still saw noticeable increases in sulfur dioxide in the atmosphere after 1850.
Air pollutants can heavily alter the appearance of landscapes in ways visible to the naked eye. Aerosols can both absorb and scatter radiation from the sun. Scattering radiation decreases the contrast between distinct objects, making them blend in more. Aerosols also scatter visible light of all wavelengths, leading to whiter hues and more intense light during the daytime.
Turner, one of Britain’s most prolific painters, witnessed the dramatic developments in his lifetime firsthand — he was born in the age of sail in 1775 and died in the age of steam and coal in 1851.
In one of his most famous works, “Rain, Steam and Speed — The Great Western Railway,” he paints a train, at the time the latest engineering marvel that allowed people to travel at unprecedented speeds, about to run over a hare, Britain’s fastest land mammal. Details in the painting, however, could almost be difficult to discern — haze and mist obscure much of the painting, an underline of the growing air pollution.
The haziness in this painting was not a fluke or one-off incident, according to the study. The team examined 60 paintings by Turner from 1796 to 1850 and 38 paintings by Monet from 1864 to 1901. Using a mathematical model, they looked at how sharp the outlines of objects were compared with the background; less contrast meant hazier conditions. They also looked at the intensity of the haze by measuring the level of whiteness; whiter hues generally indicated more intense haze.
Researchers found that around 61 percent of the contrast changes in the paintings largely tracked with increasing sulfur dioxide concentrations during that time period. (They also found a trend in whiter hues, but they put less emphasis on these results as pigments in the paintings themselves could have faded over time.)
The visual transformations are stark.
In Turner’s “Apullia in Search of Appullus,” which he painted in 1814, sharper edges and a clear sky are easily discernible. In “Rain, Steam and Speed — The Great Western Railway,” painted 30 years later, hazy skies dominate. During that time, sulfur dioxide emissions more than doubled.
The beginning of Monet’s career also differs from its end. His “Sainte-Adresse” in 1867 heavily contrasts with his Houses of Parliament series that began around 1899, when he spent time on and off in London for several months.
The team also assessed visibility, the distance at which an object can be clearly seen, and found visibility in Turner’s clear-sky and cloudy paintings before 1830 averaged about 25 kilometers but decreased to 10 kilometers after 1830. In several of Monet’s Charing Cross Bridge paintings, the farthest visible object was estimated to be about 1 kilometer away.
“Impressionism is often contrasted with realism, but our results highlight that Turner and Monet’s impressionistic works also capture a certain reality,” said co-author Peter Huybers, a climate scientist and professor at Harvard University. “Specifically, Turner and Monet seem to have realistically shown how sunlight filters through smoke and clouds.”
Perhaps, some could argue, Turner’s and Monet’s painting style just changed over the decades, giving rise to what we now call impressionistic art. But the researchers also analyzed the contrast and intensity in another 18 paintings from four other impressionist artists (James Whistler, Gustave Caillebotte, Camille Pissarro and Berthe Morisot) in London and Paris. They found the same results: Visibility in the paintings decreased as outside air pollution increased.
“When different artists are exposed to similar environmental conditions, then they paint in more similar ways,” said Albright, based at École Normale Supérieure in Paris, “even if that’s happening in different points of history.”
In its summary, the study also addressed a possible theory that Turner’s and Monet’s eyesight worsened as they aged, which could have affected their ability to paint a clear landscape. But Turner painted objects in clear detail in the foreground of paintings while successfully blurring those in the background, Albright said. Monet also didn’t develop cataracts until decades after he started his impressionistic paintings.
Ophthalmologists, the authors said in an interview, have also evaluated the artists’ vision. Michael Marmor, an ophthalmology professor at Stanford, has said: “Monet was not myopic; Turner did not have cataracts.”
Additionally, Monet’s letters to his wife while living in London provide additional compelling evidence that he was acutely aware of the environmental changes around him. In some letters, he even laments the absence of the new industries to spark his creativity: “Everything is as if dead, no train, no smoke or boat, nothing to excite the verve a bit.”
Art historian James Rubin, who was not involved in the research, said the study was fascinating for its analysis of pigments and the progression of blurriness.
“The study … provides an empirical basis for what art historians have observed,” said Rubin, who is a professor emeritus of art history at Stony Brook University, State University of New York. “These artists were certainly concerned with and were in a period of atmospheric change.”
Rubin added that both artists drew inspiration from surrounding environmental changes but certainly from different perspectives. He sums it up: Turner was generally anti-modern. Monet was ready to celebrate modernity, which to him signaled change.
For instance, Rubin said it is now generally understood that “Rain, Steam and Speed — The Great Western Railway” is not a celebration of a new technology.
“Anyone who thinks about the look of the train can see that it’s nothing but a furnace on wheels,” he said. “Many people feared the speed at which these engines could travel — about 35 mph.”
In contrast, Monet reveled in the aesthetic effects of sunlight bouncing off clouds in the polluted air and “celebrates the spectacle of modern change,” Rubin said.
Portrayals of environmental changes or meteorology in paintings are not new. Some meteorologists argue that Edvard Munch’s “The Scream” depicts polar stratospheric clouds. Some have pinpointed the Vincent van Gogh’s “Moonrise” to exactly 9:08 p.m. on July 13, 1889, in Saint Rémy de Provence, France. Turner’s other paintings accurately depicted sunsets during volcanic eruptions, which appear redder due to scattering through the aerosol-laden stratosphere.
Atmospheric scientist Fred Prata, who analyzed the meteorology in Munch’s “The Scream,” said this study reinforces his view “that art and science are much more correlated than most people believe.”
Albright said this study, to her knowledge, is “the first to look at anthropogenic changes in the environment and how artists might capture that in painting on canvas” and through time.
Artists and others living at the time in London and Paris “were aware of changes in air pollution and really engaging with those changes,” Albright said. “Maybe that could be a sort of parallel to today of how society and how artists respond to these unprecedented changes that we’re experiencing,” she said.
order tadalafil 10mg pills cialis tadalafil ed pills online
isotretinoin 20mg pills brand amoxicillin 500mg azithromycin sale
buy azipro online cheap cheap neurontin without prescription buy gabapentin 800mg pill
furosemide 100mg pills buy albuterol 2mg online cheap order albuterol online
order levitra 10mg vardenafil pill buy plaquenil 400mg pills
levitra 20mg price tizanidine buy online order plaquenil 200mg generic
order altace generic order amaryl 1mg sale arcoxia 120mg cost
buy olmesartan 10mg generic order depakote online cost divalproex
generic asacol 400mg cheap mesalamine irbesartan for sale
order coreg 6.25mg purchase chloroquine pills chloroquine 250mg pills
diamox sale diamox pills order imuran generic
order lanoxin for sale digoxin us order molnunat sale
naprosyn 500mg uk naprosyn ca buy prevacid 30mg pill
olumiant 2mg ca purchase olumiant without prescription lipitor 40mg for sale
proventil cheap how to buy albuterol pyridium 200mg tablet
cost singulair buy symmetrel 100mg generic buy avlosulfon 100 mg generic
order amlodipine 5mg buy zestril 10mg generic purchase omeprazole without prescription
nifedipine brand order aceon 8mg order allegra 180mg pill
buy priligy 60mg pill buy xenical 120mg without prescription order xenical pills
buy lopressor 100mg generic buy methylprednisolone uk methylprednisolone 8mg over counter
purchase triamcinolone pills desloratadine pill buy claritin 10mg online cheap
cost diltiazem 180mg acyclovir 800mg price buy zyloprim 300mg without prescription
buy rosuvastatin 20mg for sale buy generic motilium domperidone 10mg oral
ampicillin 500mg generic buy metronidazole 400mg for sale metronidazole tablet
purchase tetracycline generic buy tetracycline 500mg sale ozobax order online
septra usa cephalexin 250mg uk buy cleocin cheap
toradol tablet toradol 10mg oral brand inderal 20mg
erythromycin 250mg usa buy tamoxifen generic buy generic nolvadex over the counter
buy clopidogrel 75mg pill order methotrexate 10mg without prescription coumadin 2mg cost
buy reglan for sale losartan drug buy generic nexium
methocarbamol online robaxin 500mg over the counter order generic suhagra
topiramate 100mg tablet where can i buy imitrex levofloxacin online buy
purchase avodart pills dutasteride brand buy mobic sale
celebrex 200mg cost purchase ondansetron pill ondansetron 8mg cost
buy aldactone 100mg online order valacyclovir 500mg generic valtrex 1000mg brand
how to get tretinoin without a prescription where can i buy avanafil order avana 200mg online cheap
proscar 1mg pill canadian viagra viagra 100mg cheap
buy tadalafil online diclofenac 50mg drug purchase indocin online cheap
online cialis cialis 20 mg price buy viagra 100mg pill
buy terbinafine 250mg generic amoxicillin generic trimox online order
cialis 20mg canada buy ed pills paypal buy cheap generic ed pills
anastrozole canada buy biaxin 250mg generic catapres 0.1mg drug
sulfasalazine 500mg ca buy cheap generic azulfidine order verapamil for sale
depakote over the counter order isosorbide 40mg sale order imdur sale
buy meclizine medication generic minocin 100mg buy generic minocin 100mg
cost imuran 50mg purchase micardis pill telmisartan 20mg sale
buy ed pills fda buy sildenafil 100mg online purchase sildenafil online cheap
buy molnunat medication order naproxen 250mg pills buy cefdinir 300mg online
best erection pills buy tadalafil 10mg for sale cialis 20mg brand
buy phenazopyridine 200mg pill cost amantadine generic symmetrel
top ed pills order tadalafil 5mg without prescription buy cialis 5mg for sale
buy avlosulfon buy adalat generic order aceon pill
fexofenadine 180mg pills allegra 120mg oral buy glimepiride 1mg online cheap
buy terazosin 5mg online order actos online tadalafil 20mg sale
buy generic arcoxia for sale azelastine 10 ml over the counter oral astelin
cordarone 100mg price buy phenytoin pill buy phenytoin 100mg
irbesartan 150mg tablet order avapro 150mg online cheap buspar buy online
buy oxytrol without a prescription oxytrol without prescription fosamax 70mg for sale
order albendazole 400mg sale albenza tablet medroxyprogesterone 10mg oral
praziquantel pill periactin without prescription generic cyproheptadine 4mg
furadantin 100mg canada motrin 400mg canada oral pamelor 25mg
order luvox 100mg online purchase luvox generic buy cymbalta 40mg online
paracetamol 500 mg sale paracetamol 500mg pills pepcid for sale online
purchase glucotrol generic betamethasone 20gm cheap buy betnovate 20 gm creams
anafranil uk where can i buy sporanox order progesterone 200mg
prograf drug requip cheap requip 1mg over the counter
calcitriol 0.25 mg uk buy generic labetalol for sale purchase fenofibrate without prescription
valsartan price order combivent 100 mcg for sale combivent 100mcg tablet
order trileptal 600mg generic actigall usa order urso 300mg without prescription
dexamethasone 0,5 mg sale order starlix pills nateglinide usa
buy bupropion 150 mg sale oral bupropion 150 mg strattera 25mg brand
captopril for sale online buy carbamazepine online cheap buy carbamazepine online
order seroquel generic escitalopram pills escitalopram 10mg ca
buy generic prozac for sale oral fluoxetine 20mg order letrozole 2.5mg sale
combivir over the counter purchase zidovudine accupril 10mg over the counter
oral frumil adapalene online zovirax medication
bisoprolol 5mg price myambutol buy online oxytetracycline us
valcivir 1000mg uk valcivir price buy floxin generic
purchase vantin online cheap buy vantin generic purchase flixotide without prescription
buy keppra 1000mg generic order bactrim 480mg pills sildenafil 25mg
zaditor cheap ziprasidone 80mg brand order generic tofranil
minoxytop online over the counter ed pills that work medicine erectile dysfunction
where to buy acarbose without a prescription prandin order fulvicin sale
buy generic aspirin online zovirax tubes buy imiquimod online
melatonin 3mg ca norethindrone 5mg sale order danazol without prescription
dipyridamole 100mg cost order pravastatin 10mg online buy pravastatin 10mg pills
duphaston drug buy empagliflozin 10mg generic jardiance 25mg over the counter
fludrocortisone order buy generic loperamide buy loperamide cheap
buy etodolac cheap colospa brand cilostazol 100 mg oral
buy prasugrel 10mg buy dimenhydrinate detrol 1mg pills
pyridostigmine for sale online piroxicam cheap buy maxalt 10mg generic
ferrous 100mg generic actonel 35mg cost sotalol ca
buy vasotec 10mg online vasotec where to buy lactulose buy online
order latanoprost sale buy xeloda 500mg online exelon 3mg ca
buy generic betahistine for sale buy latanoprost without prescription benemid buy online
premarin drug buy premarin 0.625mg for sale us viagra sales
order omeprazole 20mg generic prilosec 10mg ca order lopressor 50mg online
canadian cialis and healthcare order cialis order generic sildenafil
buy micardis 20mg pills buy hydroxychloroquine 400mg online cheap molnupiravir tablet
generic cenforce 100mg buy naproxen online cheap buy aralen 250mg sale
modafinil drug order provigil 100mg buy prednisone 5mg pill
order cefdinir 300mg buy prevacid 15mg online lansoprazole 30mg cheap
buy azithromycin 250mg online cheap gabapentin for sale buy neurontin 600mg without prescription
buy lipitor 40mg generic lipitor 10mg pills norvasc order
best real casino online lasix 100mg without prescription buy furosemide 100mg
purchase pantoprazole order lisinopril 5mg pill buy phenazopyridine 200mg pills
slots free online acticlate medication oral ventolin 4mg
poker online cash online roulette real money ivermectin 6 mg for people
buy amantadine 100 mg online cheap amantadine 100 mg brand oral avlosulfon 100mg
real money casino online usa levothroid for sale synthroid 100mcg sale
clomid over the counter isosorbide 20mg for sale buy imuran 25mg
methylprednisolone 16mg tablet buy triamcinolone 10mg without prescription order triamcinolone 4mg online cheap
order generic dilantin 100 mg cost oxybutynin 2.5mg oxybutynin pills
buy generic aceon 4mg buy allegra 180mg online cheap allegra over the counter
buy generic lioresal for sale generic lioresal how to get ketorolac without a prescription
order claritin generic buy claritin 10mg online cheap priligy 30mg sale
buy generic fosamax over the counter macrodantin us macrodantin 100 mg price
buy glimepiride 4mg sale order etoricoxib generic arcoxia over the counter
inderal online inderal online plavix 150mg canada
cheap nortriptyline 25mg how to get pamelor without a prescription purchase anacin online cheap
how to get medex without a prescription paroxetine 20mg usa buy metoclopramide paypal
xenical pills order generic mesalamine 400mg generic diltiazem
cheap famotidine 40mg losartan pill buy generic prograf 5mg
order esomeprazole generic mirtazapine for sale topiramate 100mg without prescription
order generic sumatriptan 25mg buy levofloxacin 250mg avodart oral
allopurinol online buy cost crestor 20mg brand crestor
brand zantac buy celebrex 200mg pills cheap celebrex
buspar over the counter buy generic buspirone 5mg buy cordarone 200mg sale
tamsulosin brand oral ondansetron 8mg simvastatin 20mg pills
motilium 10mg pills brand motilium 10mg buy generic sumycin online
order spironolactone pills order spironolactone 25mg sale how to get finasteride without a prescription
term papers writing how to write a hiring letter buy custom research paper
order fluconazole 100mg online order ampicillin 250mg buy cheap ciprofloxacin
order sildenafil generic estradiol 2mg canada estradiol tablet
purchase metronidazole generic keflex 250mg cheap keflex usa
order lamotrigine sale minipress cheap vermox over the counter
buy clindamycin online cheap cleocin for sale online fildena 100mg price
purchase tretinoin for sale buy tadalafil generic avana for sale
buy tamoxifen 20mg for sale budesonide buy online buy symbicort inhalers
purchase tadalafil generic tadalafil price indocin order online
order axetil pill purchase ceftin without prescription robaxin 500mg over the counter
trazodone 50mg without prescription oral suhagra 100mg buy clindac a without prescription
purchase lamisil generic terbinafine cheap best casino slots online
aspirin price no deposit bonus codes online blackjack spins website
cheap dissertation help help with math homework online cefixime 100mg generic
speechwriters slots free online play free roulette games
calcitriol 0.25mg cheap labetalol pill fenofibrate 160mg cost
acne medication prescribed by doctors best acne treatment for adults oral trileptal 600mg
how to get clonidine without a prescription buy clonidine 0.1 mg sale spiriva online
purchase alfuzosin without prescription claritin allergy sinus 12hr costco prescription heartburn medicine names
minocycline 100mg canada order minocin 50mg online requip 1mg tablet
sleeping tablets prescribed by doctors top 10 hair loss products webmd weight loss supplements
order letrozole generic femara 2.5 mg brand aripiprazole pill
supplements to quit smoking cigarettes states that offer free nrt list of painkillers by name
medroxyprogesterone 10mg generic praziquantel over the counter microzide 25mg brand
medications prescribed for shingles buy inhalers for asthma online feline insulin dosage chart
buy generic cyproheptadine for sale how to get periactin without a prescription order nizoral sale
lamisil for toenail fungus reviews lamisil for toenail fungus reviews antihypertensive drug chart
duloxetine 40mg over the counter glucotrol 5mg pills order modafinil 200mg generic
purchase phenergan buy generic ed pills over the counter cheap stromectol
get contraceptive pill online volume pills concerns pills that increase semen volume
prednisone 20mg oral buy accutane 20mg without prescription buy amoxil 500mg online
best natural supplements for gerd foods that cause smelly flatulence the best gas reducing relief
buy azithromycin 500mg sale brand omnacortil gabapentin for sale
ursodiol without prescription zyban us purchase cetirizine generic
strattera pills strattera 25mg oral oral sertraline
buy lexapro 10mg online cheap buy prozac 40mg generic order revia 50mg pill
furosemide 100mg price purchase doxycycline generic purchase albuterol online cheap
order generic ipratropium buy ipratropium 100mcg generic zyvox price
augmentin 375mg sale synthroid 100mcg brand clomiphene buy online
buy starlix 120 mg without prescription buy captopril 25 mg sale buy cheap generic candesartan
order nateglinide 120mg pills order generic nateglinide brand atacand 8mg
buy carbamazepine pills for sale ciprofloxacin pill order lincocin 500mg pills
order cenforce 50mg pills order aralen 250mg generic buy glucophage 500mg for sale
buy cefadroxil medication buy duricef online cheap buy combivir pill
buy generic lipitor 40mg buy zestril for sale buy generic lisinopril over the counter
brand dostinex 0.25mg how to buy dostinex priligy drug
medrol over the counter order triamcinolone pills clarinex 5mg drug
cheap cytotec 200mcg order diltiazem generic buy diltiazem 180mg
nootropil 800mg drug anafranil 25mg usa buy generic clomipramine for sale